Published note: 2018-11-26
Mexico City, November 26, 2018.- In a conversation with CoinDesk newspaper, Richard Stallman, who founded the free software shift, has debated discussions such as Bitcoin and freedom. In his opinion, the use of his "libertarianism" terms with bitcoiners is unsure: "The rights that played an important part of the Bitcoin armies are not always worthy of the label. "
Stallman is a guru for computing scientists. As a programmer, we recognize the creation, among others, of GNU Emacs text editor, GCC compiler, GDB debugger and GNU Make language; All under the GNU project rule. But his fame is linked to his views on the left, for many political comments on free software subject. Indeed, in some countries such as Venezuela they know it well, since it was involved in promoting free software in a variety of state organizations, including an oil company PDVSA of state.
Your idea of Bitcoin
Initially, CoinDesk makes it clear: although many may think that a Bitcoin fan is a free software appliance, Stallman is not. In fact it is a belief.
He told CoinDesk that Bitcoin does not fit into a digital payment system. His biggest complaint: poor privacy bitcoin privacy. He said:
The things I would like to be in the way to make anonymous buy in different types of sources, and unfortunately I could not do Bitcoin.
Using cryptographic exchange would be that company and, at a & # 39; Eventually, the government wants to mark it, he said. And regarding Bitcoin's mining, he emphasized: "I have other things I can do".
When asked what he was to think about the privacy funds of my friend; name, Stallman said he had been appointed to an expert to evaluate his ability, and "for each one he sent out some of the problems, and maybe due to their security or safety. "
And speaking widely, Stallman continued:
If Bitcoin security privacy is possible, it might be possible to locate it for its use.
And he said:
I would not want perfect privacy because this would mean that it would not be possible to investigate the crime. And that is one of the jobs we need to do the State.
GNU and payment system
The GNU Project, set up by Stallman, is working on a different digital payment system called Taler, which is based on cryptography but is not a downturn.
Keeper of the Taler project, Christian Grothoff, told CoinDesk that the system, instead, is designed for the "post-Blockchain" world.
Taler shares some of the sides with the cryptocurrency projects, especially aimed at completing the same.
It is based on blind signatures, a cryptographic method created by David Chaum, who had DigiCash one of the first attempts to create secure electronic money. In addition, Taler's attempt to create digital money that impedes control over governments and paying companies is in place; Combined with many decline projects.
However, Taler does not try to avoid a central authority. Payments are handled by "exchanges" rather than instead of network of consensus staff because, according to Grothoff, such a system would "allow for dangerous use and cash cleansing."
In fact, in breaking up with the opposition to government that is likely to be & # 39; identifying Bitcoin and some of its co-workers, Taler's design is trying to block opportunities to stop taxes.
The privacy in the Taler system, then, is limited to consumers to spend their digital money. They are protected from scrutiny because, according to Grothoff, "the exchange, when the medals can not be delivered, can notify whether it is a consumer A or B B or customer C They got the money, because they're all like the exchange. "
"No one knows," he said, "who knows how many skipper?"
On the other hand, the merchandise (or any person) receives payments in another open and transparent manner, which enables tax governments to be assessed on the income, without to & # 39; mentions that it is harder for beneficiaries to take part in a laundry of money.
Place for fragments?
Although Taler is not in decline and there is no indigenous resource (no talers or TalerCoins), as a new payment line for the assets; , the system may be able to support cryptocurrency at a time.
Like euros (the first money that can be supported by the system), dollars and yen can be used; using Taler, as well as Bitcoin.
In the same way, although Taler is not a series of blocks, a system of blocks based on a bank place within the system could be.
However, so that users can be able to move an image into Taler's opinion, traders' interchanges need to interact with the traditional bank system to withdraw that money. In the same way, a system based on Blockchain could work with Taler interchanges to allow the users to access the terminals.
Grothoff compared to the transfer of bank resources to the Taler digital phase to attract money from ATM. The medals in the leaflet are stored locally on a user's device, and if a user is in a position; Missing the key to their product, nothing can be done to restore it, such as using private / public pairs in encryption.
At this time, Taler talks to European banks to allow him to attract the Taler barrel and also restore the Taler system into the traditional bank system.
Although the launch date on the project's website is not yet ready, Grothoff said, it depends on how fast & # 39; as far as possible, the negotiations with the banks will be decided. And he said: "Banks are not easy or cheap to deal with."
However, there is nothing about the traditional banking system according to all necessary to work the Taler (except for regulatory compliance). In principle, the "system based on registries" called Taler could be a bank account or, in theory, a series of blocks, Grothoff said.
If Taler acquires land, developers can try to create different activities and equality, use any of their banks or barriers or any registration system. After that, Grothoff said:
Software is free.