Changing the P.E.I. Votes may "mitigate" issues "or simply bring a" new, fair voting system "depending on what you talk to.
Both options in the forthcoming referendum on referendum have been discussed, discussed and selected on behalf of a public forum held by CBC P.EI. Thursday.
The referendum will be held on Tuesday, 23 April, 2019, in conjunction with the regional election, and asked voters "Should The Prince of Wales convert his voting system to a shared voting system?" are members mixed? "
Those who choose “yes” vote for proportionality (MMP), a form of proportional representation, and those who choose "not" vote to vote for the biggest voting system t .
The forum, held at Stonepark Intermediate School in Charlottetown, was filled with a few hundred people – including current and past politicians, candidates on both sides and people who have not. decide how they intended to vote.
The ability for small governments
Brenda Oslawsky by Vote P. P…I. an argument that regional legislature would make parties work together by providing more party seats. “We will create the agreed government that many people say demand on the island,” she said. "No party has power."
She said P.E.I. he has a history of "lopsided parts" which have challenges against one or two members, meaning she will not serve voters.
Iain Barrett, a No What to Vote, disagreed with her position saying that MMP would “give little promise to small governments.” T
“The pressures are that they will be more of a backdrop and that parties that have found most of the seats will reflect some of the policies and principles that have been chosen. Firstly, it would be possible if they were to hold the partnership together. , said he.
Misunderstanding and difficulty
Some listeners raised concerns about signage and leaflets from the campaign. No what to Vote encourages people "If you don't know, vote."
A member of the audience asked Betty Wilcox to Barrett to explain and justify that campaign message.
“If you want to say to someone just because you don't understand fully what MMP means, so follow the old status quo, it's quite careless, it's a bit wrong. like the other side, 'If you need to make a measurement, vote';
Barrett said the campaign was encouraging people to learn more – but not brushing up with the idea.
Gerard Mitchell, referendum commissioner P.E.I. Should the bear behind MMP not be a barrier to voters.
"They shouldn't be discouraged by everything, more than anyone is driving and enjoying the car by car. They don't need to be mechanized," they said. said he.
"It's simple. Forty per cent of the vote should be equivalent to forty per cent of the seats. If an Islander arranges a ballot, they should choose someone who votes with that," said Oslawsky.
“It is confusing and complex to just describe the results of our current system,” she said.
One member of audience from Western P.E.I. He spoke about the schools that could close in 2017 as an example of how the first place worked well, especially for the rural communities of the area.
Jason Ramsey, with We the West, said his organization was able to bid successfully MLAs to decide to close the local school – it would not be possible for him to do something that would concern him MMP.
“When we take that same model and look at MMP we only have about two and a half enough to try and hear our voice," Ramsey said.
He also expressed concerns that a smaller MMP of representatives could represent for rural parts of P.E.I., particularly for the second ballot.
"We are very nervous as a rural community, during election times people don't choose to have their choice but it would be a feeling of lists from urban areas with more population."
But Oslawsky said that she thinks the whole situation is avoided in the first place.
“He often thinks if all the questions about school closures would come up if there was a coalition government. Then I don't think it was one party that put that particular decision on the people, and it needed a lot of public initiatives. "
Will it be implemented?
Others had questions about whether the referendum vote was binding, and what the decision will be about the future.
Mitchell explained to the audience that the vote had received at least 50 per cent of the vote across the island, and at least 50% in the 17 areas of Skye going out, and then according to the government's PEI Referendum Act. undertake to bring forward legislation to implement the MMP system. But he said that a new government could change.
“If the legislator could make a law, the legislator can change a law,” he said, explaining a future government will make sure it doesn't follow the referendum results.
"It gives no power to the people, I mean that it just gives us the chance to hear our voice, but that does not affect the change unless you are interested t Parliament was going to go through the legislation, ”said a member of the audience, Trevor Matheson.
But Mitchell said there will be political pressure on whatever government is chosen to take action if there is a vote for change. "Wrap it like this, if it was to win the end of the referendum for the referendum vote, it would be an extremely difficult political situation for a party to fare and not to uphold that vote after such a referendum. result. "
Look at all the forum
More P.E.I. news. t